Fitch winks a AAA...

On August 16, 2011, Fitch Ratings confirmed its AAA rating for the US sovereign debt. Whether it was an anti-climactic no-brainer after witnessing the fiasco of the S&P downgrade, or Fitch corporate insight that it may just be too early to throw the towel in on US sovereigns given the response the markets gave to the rival's downgrade is irrelevant except to seers and their jury. In fact,  the sequitur- Treasuries rose in price and equities tumbled,  the dollar surged as capital flowed into the US for the short term was predictable. Meanwhile, an overly cautious European financial system and European AAAs tried to make sense of their own regional fiasco in light of this US resurgence. It was a perfect storm for Fitch to stall on, without sinking.

Analysts Messrs. Riley, Olert, Renwick and Fitch management should be commended for their approach and narrative: 

"The affirmation of the US 'AAA' sovereign rating reflects the fact that the key pillars of US's exceptional creditworthiness remains intact: its pivotal role in the global financial system and the flexible, diversified and wealthy economy that provides its revenue base. Monetary and exchange rate flexibility further enhances the capacity of the economy to absorb and adjust to 'shocks'."

The narrative accompanying the affirmation reflects a humble appreciation of the mission of the Rating Agencies, a subtle recognition that the US financial structure can accommodate internal and external tensions and 'shocks', support the demands of its financial and trade partners, and a realistic understanding of the US position as underpinning the global economic system. It was a reasonable call in the case of the United States- a sovereign that could not default, although Fitch nudged away from that premise by mitigating the controversy with ' the risk of sovereign default remains extremely low.'  Notwithstanding the wink,

...Fitch also wagged the finger

Ten days later,  on  August 25, 2011, Fitch London Research Paper  released its conclusions on the global consequences of a hypothetical "double-dip recession" in the US.  At the time of  the original affirmation, August 16, 2011, Fitch had also confirmed its intentions to review the fiscal state and projections of the US economy in light of the latter's own commitment to reduce its deficit. The position Fitch advocates by its affirmation of the maximum rating is not as daring as some observers would judge. The reserve status of the US currency, the depth of the US markets, and the intrinsic ability of the US to satisfy its monetary obligations vis-a-vis its creditors, even in light of slowing economic growth and domestic political tension-all warrant the Fitch AAA affirmation and the ensuing qualified caution as to an imminent review, given the integral role the US plays in sustaining global economic stability. In this context, the Fitch London Research report is a timely and welcome sequitur to the affirmation of AAA.  It reiterates and confirms the soundness of those fundamental considerations that Fitch tabled and examined in the first instance to arrive at its maximum rating. It also interposes a scenario testing the consequences of a major slowdown in the US economy.  The analysis quantifies the direct, and to a much more limited extent, warns of the second round effects , including inter-financial sector effects, of a hypothetical 'double-dip' recession in the US. Fitch concludes that no country will be insulated from the adverse impact of a further deterioration in US economic activity. First, but not foremost, is China and the combined domino impact of a slowdown in the US and a commensurate drop in GDP in China on world economies will be formidable. The greatest effect of the US slowdown will be on its adjoining geographic trade partners Mexico and Canada, and seemingly the consequence will be 'severe'. The most intense will be to small and open economies. That the healthy state of the US economy is a sine qua non catalyst for any global recovery is emphasized to the point that Fitch underscores that the US dip could tip the major advanced economies into recessions, and this includes a fragile Europe and a taxed Japan. The Fitch announcement out of London preceded the prouncements by the world's leading financial figures at the 2011 Economic Policy Symposium sponsored by the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City and held in Jackson Hole, Wyoming  from August 25, 2011 through to August 27, 2011. Not only did it assemble central bankers and senior policymakers, but it also gave the world an opportunity to listen to a battered field's rising stars with daring visions among which named: Mr. Dani Rodrik and Mme.Esther Duflo.

The Fitch release set a balanced and cautious mood for the world's markets and audience, thereby permitting global policymakers to ponder the complexity of a situation that required serious reflection and sound discernment in a reserved setting. 

FitchRating acted very responsibly and very professionally.

h/t Fitch